Tuesday, February 28, 2006

Early Baptists and Tithing


Modern Baptists, particularly Southern Baptists, are some of the most ardent advocates of tithing, especially “storehouse tithing.” But is this a traditional Baptist belief?

John Smyth, a Separatist and considered by many the first ‘modern’ Baptist, said: “Wee hold that tithes are either Jewish or popish.” Roger Williams (pictured to the left), who settled in Narragansett Bay (now Providence, RI) in 1636, said that ministers should serve freely “and that not in stinted wages, tithes, stipends, salaries” are they to be paid. John Bunyan (pictured below Williams)(1628–1688), author of Pilgrim’s Progress, commented on Luke 18:10–13: “This paying of tithes was ceremonial, such as came in and went out with the typical priesthood.” Luther Powell, a tithing advocate, said (of Baptists and tithing): “By and large, the Baptists—although inconsistent at times—remained true to the principles of separation of church and state and voluntary support of the ministry. They, more than any other group, are the representatives of the philosophy of church support which emphasizes voluntary support on the congregational level.” Basically they held to freewill support rather than “salaries, wages, stipends, or tithes.”

Francis Wayland, an early Southern Baptist (1859), provided a description of providing ministerial support that is at variance with any advocacy for tithing. Early Baptists in England (1600s) were adamantly against tithing. They utilized Hebrews 7:12 to argue for the abrogation of the tithe.

Therefore, Baptists in America during this period were specifically opposed to tithing. They believed that alms were meant for the poor and that every member of the congregation should give liberally to meet the needs of their minister. However, Baptists were known for their stinginess and their ministers generally did not have an adequate income. The early Baptists did not address the issue of what percentage or proportion should be given since the amount was left for the individual to decide. Baptists were not simply ignorant of the practice, rather they formally disagreed with the tithing model. Eventually the Southern Baptist Convention adopted a statement supporting tithing in 1895. Therefore, Baptists generally did not accept tithing as obligatory for Christians from its founding (ca. 1600) to the late 1800s, almost 300 years. Therefore, how, where, and with whom, did the tithing renewal get its impetus?


References and Resources:

Barrington R. White, Association Records of the Particular Baptists of England, Wales and Ireland to 1660, 3 vols. (London: Baptist Historical Society, 1974), 1:44–45, 48, 151, 3:153–57.

Barrington E. White, “The English Particular Baptists and the Great Rebellion, 1640–1660,” Baptist History and Heritage 9 (1974): 23–28.

Edward Terrill, The Records of a Church of Christ in Bristol, 1640–1687, ed. Roger Hayden (Bristol: Bristol Record Society, 1974), 134–35.

Charles F. Dole, “The Voluntary System in the Support of Churches,” The Unitarian Review 28:22 (July 1887): 22, 24.

Luther P. Powell, Money and the Church (New York: Association Press, 1962), 91.

Francis Wayland, Notes on the Principles and Practices of Baptist Churches (New York: Sheldon, 1859), 63–64, 191–92, 237–40.

Albert L. Vail, Stewardship Among Baptists (Philadelphia: American Baptist Publication Society, 1913), 4, 7, 37, 39–40, 47, 49–50.

Southern Baptist Convention, Annual of the Southern Baptist Convention (Nashville: Executive Committee, Southern Baptist Convention, 1895), 18–24.

John Bunyan, Bunyan’s Searching Works: The Strait Gate, The Heavenly Footman, The Barren Fig-Tree, The Pharisee and Publican, and Divine Emblems (Philadelphia: American Baptist Publication Society, 1851), 24.

5 comments:

J. B. Hood said...

DC,

What is “storehouse tithing”?

dacroteau said...

It's one thing to say that Christians must give 10% or they are robbing God. However, some take it to another level by saying that Christians must give 10% to their local church, aka, "the storehouse" referred to in Malachi 3. Since Malachi 3 says that tithes are to be brought into the storehouse, and since the church is the storehouse today, all 10% must be given to the church or you are robbing God.

For a reference to this concept, see an SBC ad hoc committee that recently said (at www.biblicalrecorder.org/content/news/2006/02_22_2006/ne220206sbc.shtml): "The ad hoc committee report also calls on individual Southern Baptists to 'practice storehouse tithing as the beginning point for kingdom giving.'"

If you study where the storehouse comes from, this concept seems a bit silly (see 2 Chron 31; Neh 10-13).

tom said...

Why isn't the "gift of giving" the established method of support for pastor and church instead of tithing? It is more consistant with "salvation by grace through faith" in every aspect of a Christian's life.

Ferraz, H. S. said...

Excellent work on such subject: "Tithing is not for grace time"; BTW it's heresy. Tithing nowdays is false teaching. And there's no historic and especially biblical support for its practice for the church, Mt 11:28-30.

Poorold plowboy said...

Simply read all of Malachi. In 1:6 he starts telling about how the priests are keeping the good stuff for themselves and offering polluted bread upon the altar.

Chapter 2 verse 1 reads: "And now, O ye priests, this commandment is for you." Malachi leaves no doubt who he is preaching to.

In Chapter 3:10 he says to the priests, "Bring ye all the tithes into the storehouse, that there may be meat in mine house and prove me now here with.....

He was plainly preaching to the evil priests who were taking part of the tithes people brought to the temple and keeping it for themselves. I beg you to read it carefully and prayerfully for yourself and not let some modern day charlatan tell you that you must tithe to the church. There is no New Testament unction to do do. Early Christians sold what they had and communally shared it. Most early Christians had no money to tithe to the church under any circumstance. Tithing as a church ritual was instituted by Charlemange in 777 AD. It was and is a totally Catholic idea to get riches for Rome. Protestant churches organized after Martin Luther did not believe in tithing. That was one of the practices they were "protesting". Somehow Satan slipped the idea of tithing to enrich preachers back into the church.

John Smyth, a Separatist and considered by many the first ‘modern’ Baptist, said: “Wee hold that tithes are either Jewish or popish.” Roger Williams , who settled in Narragansett Bay (now Providence, RI) in 1636, said that ministers should serve freely “and that not in stinted wages, tithes, stipends, salaries” are they to be paid. John Bunyan (1628–1688), author of Pilgrim’s Progress, commented on Luke 18:10–13: “This paying of tithes was ceremonial, such as came in and went out with the typical priesthood.”

Please do not take my word or anyone elses, do your own Bible reading and do it praying for understanding. This tithing lie has driven far too many people away from our churches and ultimately from God. Jesus said, "My yoke is easy and my burden light." Money hungry people have created a heavy burden and a hard yoke just to enrich themselves.